Who it’s for. If your current heating plan is “I’ll just think warm thoughts and eat a gas station egg roll,” this is the upgrade. The Portable Buddy is the little red box humming in half the pop-up hubs on any Minnesota lake on a Saturday, sitting next to the minnow bucket like it pays rent. It’s built for small hubs, flip-overs and anyone who’d rather not haul a furnace across the snow.
What anglers like. On r/IceFishing, one longtime commenter called Buddy heaters “the crowd favorite” and said they seem like the most reliable and economical option. Another angler running an uninsulated Eskimo QuickFish 2 said it was always fine, though windy, cold days meant cranking it to high. The Amazon listing says it puts out 4,000 or 9,000 BTU, is rated for about 225 square feet and has a low-oxygen shutoff. More than 29,000 Amazon ratings average 4.7 stars. That’s roughly a whole lake town agreeing on something, which up here usually only happens about hotdish.
The gripes. Moisture, mostly. Run it a while and the inside of the shelter grows a frosty little beard, the same commenter warned. Folks in a bigger-shelter thread suggest the Big Buddy for large hubs, a small fan to push warm air down from the ceiling, and keeping the heater up off the ice so you aren’t brewing slush. In Aing’s much-watched test video, he noticed a strong smell as a cylinder ran dry. And everybody, from the manual to the forum, lands in the same place: vent the shelter and carry a battery CO alarm. That’s not a vibe. That’s the rule.
The verdict. For a small shelter, anglers are close to unanimous: this is the heater you buy first and stop thinking about. Bring spare cylinders, crack a vent, and enjoy the strange luxury of taking your gloves off on a frozen lake.